In October 2026, WorkSafe Victoria charged a 42-year-old Melton man over WorkCover payments totalling $251,001. It is alleged he received the payments between October 2021 and May 2025 without telling WorkSafe he was working, and that he submitted certificates of capacity falsely stating he had not worked. In March, a separate case alleged $411,914 in WorkCover payments obtained by misrepresenting working hours and earnings. Both matters are before the Melbourne Magistrates’ Court and have not been decided.
For employers, cases like these are a reminder of an uncomfortable reality. Most claims and absences are genuine. When one is not, the cost lands on the business: premiums, lost productivity, overtime to cover the gap, and the effect on staff who see it happening.
The question is not whether to act. It is how to establish the facts first, lawfully, so any action you take will hold.
The real cost of acting on suspicion alone
When a manager suspects an employee is exaggerating an injury, working elsewhere while on paid leave, or using work time for a side business, the temptation is to confront them. That is usually the most expensive option.
An allegation without evidence invites a dispute. If the suspicion is wrong, the business has damaged a working relationship and may face a claim. If the suspicion is right but unproven, the employee is warned, behaviour changes, and the opportunity to establish what was happening is often lost.
Evidence changes the position. It allows the business to make a decision based on facts rather than impressions, and to defend that decision if it is challenged.
Where surveillance fits
Surveillance is the systematic observation and recording of a person’s activities, conducted lawfully and reported so it can be relied on. For employers, it is most useful where the question is about what someone is physically doing, and where that conflicts with what they have said.
Common situations include:
- Extended absences where an employee is reported to be active, working or travelling while on paid leave.
- Secondary employment that may breach an employment contract, conflict of interest policy or restraint.
- Misuse of work time or company assets, such as vehicles or equipment used for private work.
- Restraint of trade concerns, where a current or departing employee may be dealing with clients or competitors.
WorkCover claims: know who does what
WorkCover matters follow a specific process, and employers should understand it before acting.
Under WorkSafe Victoria’s claims manual, it is the claims agent that arranges surveillance when there is an allegation of potential scheme abuse. Allegations can come from many sources, including employers. Where a claim is found to have been obtained fraudulently, employers can seek a recalculation of their premium for that part of the claim costs.
In practice, this means an employer with a genuine concern about a WorkCover claim should document what they know and raise it with the agent, rather than commissioning their own surveillance of that claim. For matters outside the WorkCover scheme, such as personal leave, secondary employment or restraint concerns, an employer can engage a licensed investigator directly.
What lawful surveillance can and cannot do
The value of surveillance evidence depends entirely on how it was gathered. Evidence obtained unlawfully can be excluded, and it can expose the business to liability.
In Victoria, licensed investigators can generally observe and record a person in public places, such as streets, shopping centres, parks and workplaces, and follow them at a distance to document their movements. They cannot enter private property without permission, film inside a person’s home, or record private conversations without consent. These limits come from the Surveillance Devices Act 1999 (Vic) and related obligations, and they are not negotiable.
A professional surveillance operation is planned around these boundaries. That includes deciding where the subject can lawfully be observed, how many operatives are needed, and what the evidence needs to show to answer the business’s question.
What a court-defensible surveillance report includes
Footage alone is rarely enough. Evidence that holds up when challenged usually includes:
- Clear, time-stamped video with the subject identifiable.
- A continuous log of observations, locations and times.
- Detailed investigator notes recorded as events happen.
- Documented continuity, showing how the footage was handled from capture to report.
- An investigator able to give evidence about what they observed, if required.
This is the difference between material that raises a question and evidence that answers it.
Before you call an investigator
A short, factual brief makes any surveillance operation faster and more cost-effective. Before the first conversation, it helps to have:
- A clear statement of what the business needs to know, in one or two sentences.
- The relevant dates, such as the period of leave or the start of the claim.
- What the employee has said about their capacity, availability or activities.
- Any information already received, and where it came from.
- Known addresses, vehicles and regular routines, where the business holds them lawfully.
Keep the circle small. The fewer people who know a concern is being looked into, the better the chance of observing normal behaviour.
What this means for you
If something about a claim, absence or employee’s activities does not add up, the most cost-effective step is usually the quietest one: establish the facts before anyone is confronted.
The RIVICA team conducts lawful, discreet surveillance for Victorian businesses, with reporting prepared to stand up to scrutiny in a tribunal or court. Richard James leads every engagement, drawing on 34 years of operational experience across two countries and two legal systems, including covert surveillance management and workplace regulation. Trained RIVICA investigators deliver each operation.
If a matter in your business needs clear answers, book a confidential consultation at rivica.com.au.
Frequently asked questions
Can an employer legally put an employee under surveillance?
For matters outside the WorkCover scheme, a business can engage a licensed investigator to observe and record an employee’s activities in public places. Surveillance must stay within Victorian surveillance and privacy laws, which prohibit filming inside a home or recording private conversations without consent.
Should we commission surveillance on a WorkCover claim ourselves?
Generally, no. Under WorkSafe Victoria’s claims manual, the claims agent arranges surveillance where there is an allegation of scheme abuse. Employers can raise concerns with the agent, and can seek a premium recalculation where costs were obtained fraudulently.
Will the employee know they are being observed?
A professional operation is conducted discreetly. Its purpose is to record normal activity as it happens, not to influence it.


